Spearhead Audio Book Review

Spearhead: An American Tank Gunner, His Enemy, and a Collision of Lives in World War II

Authored by Adam Makos, Narrated by Johnathan McClain

Audiobook, 13 hours and 33 minutes

Published by Random House Audio

Language: English

ASIN: B07M5HL8N2

The Spearhead was the U.S. Army’s 3rd Armored Division.  Specifically, the author follows the story of the Division’s 32rd Armored Regiment and 36th Armored Infantry Regiment as they fought their way across Europe and into Germany.  They are the units which were immortalized in the famous newsreel film of the tank duel in Cologne, and the report of that fight from a young war correspondent named Andy Rooney.

The author relies heavily on interviews from the actual participants, and allows the story to unfold in their own words.  There are several perspectives from the American side, and even a few from the German.  The reader gets a ground-level narrative of armored warfare and combined arms assaults, along with the terrible attrition as units remained in the front lines day after day.

There is no sugar coating the assault on Germany.  The American tankers were fighting with inferior equipment, and they knew it.  There is open distain for the Sherman tank whose gun could not defeat the frontal armor of many German tanks, and whose armor could not protect the crews from the German’s guns.  The Panther was a feared opponent, and could only be defeated if the Shermans were able to survive long enough to maneuver for a side shot.  In the last few months one of the American crews was issued a new Pershing which evened the odds, but most of the Regiment finished the war on the Sherman.

The German story is represented as well, from the perspective of Gustav Schaefer, a Panther crewman.  The Germans faced a deteriorating war situation against overwhelming odds.  Shaefer’s tanks was one of the few which survived to defend Cologne against the American onslaught, the reader is shown the battle for the city from his perspective.

This book is treasure for anyone wanting to study armored warfare on the Western Front.  The American way of war is the combined arms assault, the Germans employed a fluid defense in depth.  Each battle is the clash of these doctrines in detail from the viewpoint of those involved.  This story is well told and engaging, highly recommended.

14 thoughts on “Spearhead Audio Book Review

    1. I enjoyed it Warren, likely you would as well. While I prefer reading it in hardback the audiobooks can be enjoyed while doing other things so I’ve been more able to do that lately.

      Liked by 2 people

  1. I was pretty stoked to see this one… until I read the description.
    In this day and age with all of the research and information available people are still spouting misinformation about the “inferior” Sherman. After reading the description I quickly lost interest.

    Liked by 2 people

      1. There were several incidents where the gunners got good hits on German AFVs and reported their rounds being deflected, while the German guns penetrated completely through the Sherman. There was also a news reporter who interviewed several tankers who were very critical of the Sherman’s gun and armor liabilities, the crews were worried they would be disciplined for speaking frankly. The Panther was much-feared. I have read about US tankers using White Phosphorous against German armor, as they knew their AP rounds wouldn’t penetrate but that the ventilation system would draw in the WP and force the crew to abandon, there is one instance of that reported in this book by the German gunner. They bailed out after a WP hit from an M7 Priest, firing in direct fire. The Panther survived several hits, one of which wrecked the running gear. The US crews felt they were at a disadvantage, but kept pressing on. The book is well worth the time to read, even if you don’t agree with the crews’ opinions of the Sherman.

        Like

  2. Yeah, since I never crewed a Sherman in combat, it’s kind of hard for me to refute opinions of those that did, whether their opinions were valid or not, The perception of the Sherman being “less than” whether it truly was or not, has an effect on morale and effectiveness. They were there. None of us were.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s