Category: Works in Progress
Bf 109G Comparison Build – Hasegawa, Fine Molds, Tamiya, Eduard Kits – Part III
SUMMARY
The Hasegawa kit is now 30 years old and is beginning to show its age. Not that it was a bad kit for its time but it has been clearly surpassed by the newer tools. Like most Hasegawa kits the deficiencies are most apparent in the cockpit area and the wheelwells, both of which are minimalist and lack any detail. The outlets on the coolers on the undersides have been simplified and are best cut out and replaced. The nose is slightly undersized, as are the fuselage bulges for the gun breeches. On the plus side fit is good and the kit goes together without any issues. If you are not too picky this kit can make for a quick “pallet cleanser” or a practice kit for a beginning modeler, but it won’t stand up to scrutiny without some extra work.
The Fine Molds kit has been my Messerschmitt of choice for almost two decades now, and there are still a few lurking in the stash. With the exception of the later tall-tail variants just about all the major versions from the F-series on are provided for. Cockpit detail is shallow and most modelers will want to make some enhancements here as this will be visible even on closed canopy builds, thanks to the flat panels on the canopy. The canopy is molded as a single piece, so if you want to pose it open, get out the razor saw. You’ll also need the saw to drop the slats and flaps, this is time-consuming and is always a tedious part of the build for me. Build ‘em if you’ve got ‘em, but not the kit to get now if you’re buying new.
The Tamiya G-6 is an excellent kit and a joy to build, it is everything you’d expect a kit from Tamiya to be. Cockpit detail is excellent right out of the box and the canopy can be posed open to show it all off. The landing gear is well detailed and the engineering ensures proper alignment, the only issue with this is the gear must be installed during the major construction which risks breakage. I’m not put off by this but others might be. Looking at the sprues Tamiya does not appear to be planning any other versions, so the G-6 is all we’re likely to get from them. There are not a lot of options there either. There is a drop tank but none of the fairly common R6 wing gun packs, the packs on this build are spares from Eduard kits. My biggest disappointment with this kit is the need to cut out the slats and flaps, a rather surprising omission from an otherwise excellent effort.
The Eduard kits are the most detailed Messerschmitts in the scale and represent the best value – my Dual Combo pack was less than $30 from Hannants. The decal sheet provides fourteen options with stencils which is almost worth the price alone. Also included are canopy masks and PE frets. The kit itself has parts for just about any option you’d want as well as spares for the tiniest of the fiddly bits – a nice touch. There will be plenty of parts left over for the spares box! Surface textures are outstanding and feature finely engraved rivets. The biggest innovation is the kit comes with separate slats and flaps for the first time, no more cutting. You will have to pay close attention to the instructions to get the most out of this build, many of the parts options are similar and PE is always tricky to work with, but the result is a gem of a model. You could make the argument the Eduard kit is over-engineered, but the true Messerschmitt aficionado will appreciate the attention to detail and the plethora of options provided in the box. This is a more complicated build than the Tamiya kit, but the Eduard kits are the best detailed and the best value for the money.
Part I here: https://inchhighguy.wordpress.com/2024/04/19/bf-109g-comparison-build-hasegawa-fine-molds-tamiya-eduard-kits-part-i/
Bf 109G Comparison Build – Hasegawa, Fine Molds, Tamiya, Eduard Kits – Part II
Bf 109G Comparison Build – Hasegawa, Fine Molds, Tamiya, Eduard Kits – Part I
Italeri Henschel Hs 129 Build in 1/72 Scale Part II
Italeri Henschel Hs 129 Build in 1/72 Scale Part I
ICM Focke Wulf Fw 189 Uhu Build in 1/72 Scale Part III
Construction Part I here: https://inchhighguy.wordpress.com/2024/03/15/icm-focke-wulf-fw-189-uhu-build-in-1-72-scale-part-i/
ICM Focke Wulf Fw 189 Uhu Build in 1/72 Scale Part II
Construction Part III here: https://inchhighguy.wordpress.com/2024/03/29/icm-focke-wulf-fw-189-uhu-build-in-1-72-scale-part-iii/
ICM Focke Wulf Fw 189 Uhu Build in 1/72 Scale Part I
Messerschmitt Me 410 Hornisse Comparison Build Part III
Summary
Fine Molds
The Fine Molds Me 410 was released in 1996 and is a good kit for that era. There were multiple boxings issued, many of these simply had different decal sheets. The kit decals in all three of my examples were the thick type with creamy whites found in many Japanese kits, the only items I found of any use were some of the instrument decals. The cockpit detail is adequate but the cockpit decking should have some detail added as this will be visible on the finished model. The wing leading edge slats should be cut out so they can be shown dropped, this is the normal configuration when the aircraft is on the ground. The kit has sharp trailing edges on the wings and tail surfaces, the only fit issue I encountered was the need to fill the seam at one of the wingroots. The Fine Molds kit is still quite buildable so I wouldn’t rush out to the vendor’s room to sell mine if I still had any in my stash.
Airfix
The Airfix kit took everyone by surprise. Just this week Eduard released a kabuki tape mask set for this kit (you’re welcome), but don’t waste your money on the KV masks as they don’t fit and wouldn’t stick if they did. Being a new mold the details are sharp and the fit is excellent, the only need for improvement I saw was the wing trailing edges required some thinning. Cockpit detail is excellent, you may only want to add some belts to give it a finished look. The control surfaces are positionable in and of themselves or provided with optional parts for an alternative position and this includes the leading-edge slats and radiator flaps. Drop tanks are included for the wings, but I replaced mine with spares from Fine Molds Bf 109s as these looked slightly better. Neither kit included rocket launchers which would have been a nice touch. Due mainly to all the optional parts the Airfix kit has a higher parts count than the Fine Molds, and being a newer tool the details are a little sharper. The kit decals are also sharp and printed well with all the stencils represented. I found the fuel triangles to be too orange for my liking though, and the spinner spirals did not fit well. I liked the Airfix instructions, the one nit-pick here is the colors are all called out as numbers; it turns out these reference Humbrol paints, and there is no Humbrol to English dictionary included anywhere so if you don’t know 62 means brown you may be left scratching your head. In all I’d rate the Airfix kit the better of the two so if you’re in the market for a new Me 410 kit this is the one to look for.
Me 410 construction part I here: https://inchhighguy.wordpress.com/2024/02/23/messerschmitt-me-410-hornisse-comparison-build-part-i/