While the Boeing B-17 Flying Fortress was arguably one of the most important aircraft designs of the Second World War, even the best designs can be improved. Combat experience against the Luftwaffe over Europe identified the need for several potential modifications suggested by the crews. The job of evaluating those changes was given to Major Robert J. Reed. Reed was sent to Wright Field in Dayton, Ohio and given B-17E 41-9112 to experiment on.Reed replaced much of the B-17E defensive armament with components already in production for the Consolidated B-24 Liberator. The most obvious changes were mounting powered turrets in the nose and tail positions. Jagdwaffe pilots had identified the hand-held nose armament as a weak point in the Fortresses defenses, and the tail position had a very restricted field of fire. The Liberator turrets remedied both these problems at a stroke.With the nose position now occupied by a turret the bombardier was moved to a gondola under the nose, similar to the original design of the Boeing Model 299. From this position the bombardier could also function as navigator which freed up a crew position. Like many Fortresses, the Dreamboat featured her own artwork.The radio operator was moved to the nose compartment and a powered twin .50 caliber mount was installed in the old radio compartment. This eliminated both single waist gun positions while increasing the “broadside” firepower which could be brought to bear defending against a beam attack. Shifting the crew and equipment weight forward also helped correct a balance problem in the Fortress – the center of gravity was aft of the center of lift, resulting in the Fortress being tail heavy and fatiguing to fly.Reed completely redesigned the bomb bay doors. Instead of two large doors which opened into the slipstream when opened, the new bomb bay doors folded back against the fuselage sides. This not only reduced drag but was also less noticeable to intercepting Luftwaffe pilots who knew the big bombers were restricted in their ability to maneuver while on their bomb runs.The hybrid bomber was named the “Dreamboat”. One of the more important changes was not apparent when looking at the aircraft from the outside. The B-17 crew’s oxygen system was adequate, but hypoxia was potentially fatal if the system suffered damage. Reed installed a dual-feed system on the Dreamboat which increased capacity and provided redundancy, a potentially life-saving modification.The Dreamboat never saw combat, but was returned to England. Combat crews were enthusiastic about the improvements – defensive firepower and fields of fire had been improved, crew requirements were reduced from ten to eight, the CG problem had been solved, and the oxygen system and bomb bay doors were improved.In the end, the modifications demonstrated on the Dreamboat were not adopted for factory production. A premium was placed on quantity production above all else, it was felt that the changes suggested by Major Reed would prove to be too much of a disruption to the production lines, and the modifications were too extensive to be performed at the depot level. The Dreamboat would remain a dream.
Speeding production was a priority for all the combatants, even if it is counter intuitive to us today. Soviet tank production was one of the best examples.
Very true. I was also thinking of the British decision to keep the 2pdr Anti tank gun in production because the factories were tooled up for it after so many were lost in France 1940, even though the far superior 6pdr ATG was ready to go.
Quite interesting as I have the gun turrets of an unbuilt Monogram 1/48 scale B-24. But I would have to convert one of the two B-17 Gs I have though. I have decided to reblog your post on Lest We Forget II.
Reblogged this on David Knights' Weblog and commented:
A great post from Jeff “Inch High” Groves on something I had never heard of. I was aware of the YB-40, but not this.
Keep in mind that the YB-40 project and the Dreamboat were concurrent, and that many of the YB-40 innovations were incorporated into the B-17G (like the Bendix chin turret and Cheyenne tail turret). IMHO the most desirable modification remaining was the additional dorsal turret in the radio compartment and deletion of the two waist gun positions.
WHENEVER ANY FORM OF GOVERNMENT BECOMES DESTRUCTIVE OF THESE ENDS (LIFE,LIBERTY,AND THE PURSUIT OF HAPPINESS) IT IS THE RIGHT OF THE PEOPLE TO ALTER OR ABOLISH IT, AND TO INSTITUTE A NEW GOVERNMENT― Thomas Jefferson
Interesting post thanks.
Not the first time I’ve read about in WW2 that better weapons weren’t made to keep te production lines going.
Cheers,
Pete.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Speeding production was a priority for all the combatants, even if it is counter intuitive to us today. Soviet tank production was one of the best examples.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Very true. I was also thinking of the British decision to keep the 2pdr Anti tank gun in production because the factories were tooled up for it after so many were lost in France 1940, even though the far superior 6pdr ATG was ready to go.
Cheers,
Pete.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have learned something new Jeff!
LikeLiked by 1 person
It would make an interesting model!
LikeLike
Quite interesting as I have the gun turrets of an unbuilt Monogram 1/48 scale B-24. But I would have to convert one of the two B-17 Gs I have though. I have decided to reblog your post on Lest We Forget II.
LikeLiked by 1 person
https://lestweforget2015.wordpress.com/2020/02/26/what-if-b-17e-41-9112-dreamboat/
I also reblogged it on My Forgotten Hobby III.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Reblogged this on My Forgotten Hobby III and commented:
Jeff is preserving the forgotten past here.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Reblogged this on David Knights' Weblog and commented:
A great post from Jeff “Inch High” Groves on something I had never heard of. I was aware of the YB-40, but not this.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Great post. I’ve also reblogged it on my site.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks David, much appreciated!
LikeLike
Quantity over men’s lives… Typical.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Keep in mind that the YB-40 project and the Dreamboat were concurrent, and that many of the YB-40 innovations were incorporated into the B-17G (like the Bendix chin turret and Cheyenne tail turret). IMHO the most desirable modification remaining was the additional dorsal turret in the radio compartment and deletion of the two waist gun positions.
LikeLike